Chapter 22: The Vision and the Reality
Harold's reaction to the engagement news arrived with considerably more warmth than Chloe had braced herself for, a brief but genuine phone call in which he offered congratulations that sounded, for perhaps the first time since she'd known him, entirely unrehearsed.
"I confess I have some pride in how this arrangement turned out," Harold said, "even if the board's original motivations were rather more transactional than romantic. I'll admit, watching the two of you these past months, I've reconsidered several assumptions I held about what actually makes a partnership durable."
"That's remarkably generous, coming from the man who proposed the arrangement in the first place."
"I contain occasional moments of self-awareness, Ms. Carter. Soon to be Mrs. Vance, I suppose, unless you intend to keep your professional name."
"I haven't decided yet," Chloe admitted. "Viper Carter has a certain ring to it, professionally speaking."
Harold's dry laugh carried down the line, unexpectedly warm. "I look forward to seeing what you decide. Congratulations, truly, to you both."
Dorothy called shortly after Harold, her voice carrying the same warm mischief Chloe remembered from their first conversation at the family dinner months earlier. "I told you he looked lighter around you, didn't I? I claim full credit for spotting it before anyone else in this family had the sense to notice."
"You did claim that, and you were entirely right."
"I usually am, about these things. Sixty years of watching this family's romantic entanglements gives a woman considerable expertise." Dorothy's tone turned gentler. "I'm genuinely delighted for you both, dear. Don't let Constance's inevitable opinions about venues and guest counts overwhelm what actually matters here. Whatever ceremony you choose, however small, it'll be exactly right if it's actually yours."
"Thank you, Dorothy. That means considerably more than you probably realize."
"I have my moments of wisdom, buried somewhere beneath the family's general dysfunction." Dorothy laughed warmly. "Now, tell me everything about the proposal. I want every romantic detail before Constance gets to you with her production timelines."
---
Constance's reaction, by contrast, arrived considerably more elaborate, a call that began with tears and quickly transitioned into detailed venue suggestions Chloe hadn't remotely considered yet.
"The Plaza's Grand Ballroom is available in June, if we move quickly on the deposit," Constance said, barely pausing for breath. "I've already spoken to my event coordinator about preliminary guest counts. Three hundred would be appropriately scaled for a family of our standing, though I could see arguments for closer to four hundred given how much positive press this engagement has already generated."
"I've also taken the liberty of contacting a florist," Constance continued, undeterred by Chloe's gentle pushback, "who specializes in precisely the kind of elaborate arrangements this event will require. White orchids, I'm thinking, imported specifically, to photograph well against whatever venue we eventually settle on. I've also considered a string quartet versus a full orchestra, though I lean toward the latter given the scale we're discussing."
"Constance, I really think—"
"And of course we'll need to discuss the guest list carefully, given how many of the board members and their extended families will expect invitations, purely as a matter of protocol. I could send over a preliminary list this afternoon, if that would help you visualize the appropriate scope."
Chloe pressed her fingers against her temple, feeling the specific, overwhelming momentum of a woman who'd clearly already planned this entire event in her head before the actual couple had said a single word about their own preferences.
"I appreciate all of this planning," Chloe said, finding her professional composure despite the mounting pressure, "but I want to be clear — Ethan and I haven't decided on any of these details yet, and we may want something considerably different from what you're envisioning."
"Of course, of course," Constance said, though her tone suggested she'd already mentally filed this objection as a temporary hurdle rather than a genuine boundary. "I simply want to be helpful, getting the ball rolling on the logistics."
"Constance," Chloe said carefully, "I appreciate the enthusiasm, but Ethan and I haven't discussed venue or guest count at all yet."
"Well, you should discuss it soon. These things require considerable lead time, and I'd hate for the family's reputation to suffer from appearing unprepared." Constance's tone carried the particular confidence of a woman accustomed to her preferences becoming decisions. "I'll send over some initial mood boards this week, simply to get the conversation started."
Chloe hung up feeling considerably more overwhelmed than the happy morning had prepared her for, and found Ethan watching her with a knowing, slightly apologetic expression once she'd set the phone down.
Priya, when Chloe called her in a mild panic between Constance's suggestions, offered the exact practical perspective Chloe needed. "You're allowed to simply say no, you know. Repeatedly, if necessary. Constance doesn't get final say over your own wedding just because she's excited about orchids."
"I know that intellectually. It's considerably harder in practice, given how completely she's already planned this in her head."
"Then let Ethan handle her directly. This is exactly the kind of family dynamic he needs to manage, not you. You've got enough on your plate navigating your own family's excitement, let alone his." Priya's tone turned warmer. "For what it's worth, whatever you two decide, I think it should be small and genuinely yours. You've spent months performing things for other people's benefit. This is one thing that should be entirely, unapologetically about what you both actually want."
"That's good advice."
"I have my moments. Mostly because I've watched you exhaust yourself trying to please everyone else for months now, and I'd like to see you finally get something that's simply, purely yours."
---
"I heard you talking to Constance," Ethan said, once Chloe had recounted the full extent of the venue and guest count suggestions. "I could hear her voice through the phone from across the room. I take it the orchid conversation went about as well as I feared."
"She's already hired a florist, apparently. Without asking either of us."
"That sounds exactly like her. She did the same thing when my cousin Beatrice got engaged, showed up with venue suggestions before the poor woman had even told her own parents." Ethan's expression turned more serious. "I'll handle this properly, Chloe. You shouldn't have to manage my family's expectations on top of everything else you're already navigating."
She thought, curling back onto the couch beside Ethan, about how differently this entire wedding planning process might have unfolded if she'd still been the version of herself from months earlier — the one who instinctively performed whatever role each situation demanded, who might have simply absorbed Constance's elaborate vision rather than pushing back against it. She was grateful, watching Ethan scroll through backyard venue photos Mai had already started sending, that she no longer had to manage every difficult conversation entirely alone.
"I appreciate that. I don't want to seem ungrateful for her enthusiasm, but three to four hundred guests feels like an entirely different event than what I actually want to celebrate."
"It's not ingratitude. It's simply knowing what you want, which is considerably more important than accommodating enthusiasm that isn't actually about what either of us needs."
"She does this," Ethan said. "Every family event becomes an opportunity for elaborate production, regardless of what anyone else actually wants. I should have warned you more clearly."
"Three hundred to four hundred guests, Ethan. For our wedding. I don't know three hundred people, let alone four hundred I'd want watching me get married."
"I know. I'll talk to her." Ethan's jaw tightened with the particular resolve Chloe recognized from every previous confrontation with his family's expectations. "This is our wedding, not a board-approved production. I don't intend to let Constance's vision override what we actually want, the way the family's preferences overrode so much else in the early part of this arrangement."
"I don't want anything elaborate," Chloe said, some of her earlier overwhelm settling into clearer conviction. "I want something small. Immediate family, the people who've actually been there through everything — Mai, Priya, maybe Reyes. Somewhere that feels like us, not somewhere chosen for its capacity to accommodate the family's social obligations."
---
That evening, Ethan called Constance directly, Chloe listening from the couch as he navigated the conversation with a firmness she hadn't quite seen him deploy against his own family before.
"I appreciate the enthusiasm, truly," he said, "but Chloe and I have decided we want something considerably smaller. Immediate family, close friends. Somewhere private, away from press entirely."
Constance's protests carried audibly even from across the room, something about family obligation and appropriate scale for the Vance name, and Ethan's responses grew steadily more patient but no less firm.
"I understand the family has certain expectations," he said finally. "I'd ask you to understand that Chloe and I have spent the past several months learning, rather painfully, what happens when we let other people's expectations override what we actually want for ourselves. I'm not willing to make that mistake again, for something this significant."
"This isn't about respecting family tradition, Constance," Ethan continued, his tone gentle but immovable. "It's about respecting what Chloe and I actually want for our own wedding, which happens to be considerably smaller than what you've already planned. I understand this disappoints you, and I'm sorry for that. But this decision isn't available for negotiation."
There was a long pause on Constance's end, followed by something that sounded, even from across the room, like genuine hurt rather than simple disappointment. "I only wanted to help. To make sure this family's happiest moments get celebrated properly, the way they deserve."
"I know that's your intention," Ethan said, softening slightly. "And I appreciate the impulse behind it, genuinely. But 'properly celebrated' looks different to Chloe and me than it might look to you. We'd like the chance to define that for ourselves, this once."
The call ended considerably more amicably than it had begun, Constance's protests eventually softening into grudging, if disappointed, acceptance, and Ethan set the phone down with the particular exhaustion of a man who'd just navigated family politics considerably more successfully than he usually managed.
---
"How bad was it, really?" Chloe asked, once he'd rejoined her on the couch.
"Manageable. She's disappointed, but she'll adjust. I suspect she'll find some other family event to pour her production energy into eventually." Ethan settled beside her, some tension visibly draining from his shoulders. "I meant what I said, about not letting this become another performance for the family's benefit. This is ours."
"Thank you for standing firm on that. I know it's not always easy, pushing back against Constance specifically."
"You're worth pushing back against considerably scarier people than my aunt for," Ethan said, something warm and certain in it. "I've had considerable practice recently, as it happens, standing up to people who'd rather I simply defer to their preferences over yours."
Mai's reaction, once Chloe called her to debrief the entire venue saga, arrived with characteristic bluntness. "Okay, first of all, Constance sounds genuinely exhausting, and I say that with love as someone who's never even met her. Second, you should absolutely have whatever tiny, intimate wedding you actually want. Third, I've already started a mental list of backyard venue options in case you need suggestions, because apparently I've become the unofficial wedding consultant for this entire situation."
"Please add 'unofficial wedding consultant' to your job title. I'll fight HR about it personally."
"I'd wear that title with pride." Mai's tone turned more genuine. "Seriously, though. Don't let anyone talk you into something that doesn't feel like you. You've spent enough time performing for other people's expectations. This should be the one thing that's entirely, unapologetically yours."
"That's almost exactly what Priya said."
"Great minds," Mai said. "Also, I'm still campaigning hard for maid of honor, in case that wasn't clear enough from my earlier phone call."
Chloe smiled, leaning into him, the earlier overwhelm of Constance's elaborate venue suggestions finally settling into something more manageable now that they'd agreed, clearly, on what actually mattered to both of them.
---
"What would you actually want," Ethan asked, "if you could design this entirely without any family input at all? Just the two of us, imagining freely."
Chloe considered the question seriously, watching the evening light fade beyond the windows. "Somewhere outdoors, I think. Small enough that everyone attending actually knows us both personally, rather than simply being invited for appearances. My parents' backyard, maybe, or somewhere similarly unpretentious. I don't need the Plaza. I need it to feel like ours."
"That sounds considerably more appealing than anything Constance proposed," Ethan admitted. "I'd like exactly that too, honestly. Something that feels like an actual celebration, rather than another item on the family's public relations calendar."
"We'll need to find a compromise that doesn't entirely alienate your family, though. However small we keep the guest list, I imagine Harold and Constance will expect some acknowledgment."
"We'll find something that works," Ethan said. "A smaller ceremony for us, perhaps, and a separate, more public celebration afterward for the family's benefit, if that helps bridge the gap between what we actually want and what they expect."
"That sounds like a reasonable compromise," Chloe said, something settling more comfortably in her chest at the specific, practical kindness of the suggestion — a solution that honored both their own wishes and the family dynamics neither of them could entirely ignore, exactly the kind of considered balance that had come to define how they navigated everything together, months into learning how to actually build a life rather than simply perform one. "You've got it, officially," Chloe said, laughing. "I don't think anyone else has even applied for the position, so your campaign was unopposed."
"I'll take the win regardless of the competition level. Victory is victory." Mai's tone softened further. "For what it's worth, I think whatever version of this wedding you two land on is going to be genuinely beautiful, precisely because it'll actually reflect who you both are, rather than what Constance thinks a Vance family wedding should look like."
"Thank you, Mai. For everything, actually, these past several months. I don't think I've properly said that."
"You don't need to. Watching you find your way to this kind of happiness has been thanks enough, honestly. Now go plan your tiny, perfect wedding and let me start thinking about my maid of honor speech."
She hung up feeling considerably lighter than she had at any point since Constance's initial call, the accumulated support from Mai, Priya, and Dorothy settling into something solid enough to counterbalance the earlier overwhelm entirely.
Constance's disappointment lingered for several days afterward, evident in the noticeably shorter, cooler messages she sent compared to her earlier enthusiasm, but by the following weekend, true to Ethan's prediction, her attention had shifted toward planning an elaborate engagement party for the extended family instead — a compromise neither Ethan nor Chloe had explicitly suggested, but one that seemed to satisfy her need for production without requiring either of them to sacrifice their vision for the actual wedding itself.
"She's already sourcing centerpieces for the engagement party," Ethan reported, reading a lengthy text from his aunt with visible amusement. "Apparently that event can be as large as she wants, since it's not technically the wedding itself."
"That's a remarkably efficient redirection of her energy."
"Constance has always been considerably better at finding workarounds than accepting direct refusals gracefully. I'll take this particular compromise, given the alternative."
"That does actually solve the problem elegantly," Chloe said, laughing at the specific absurdity of the solution. "She gets her three hundred guests and imported orchids at a party that isn't technically the wedding, and we get our small, genuine ceremony exactly the way we want it."
"Everyone wins, in their own particular way," Ethan agreed. "Constance included, provided she never has to acknowledge she didn't get the actual wedding she originally envisioned."
"I can live with that particular fiction, if it keeps the peace."
"So can I. I've had considerable practice, this past week, choosing which battles with my family are actually worth fighting."
They settled, in the end, on a small ceremony at Chloe's parents' house in Ohio — a backyard wedding, exactly as she'd first imagined it, with barely thirty guests including immediate family, Priya, Mai, Reyes, and, after considerable discussion, a cautious invitation extended to Marcus as well. The larger engagement party, meanwhile, would proceed under Constance's enthusiastic direction at some suitably grand Manhattan venue, satisfying the family's need for public celebration without requiring either Chloe or Ethan to sacrifice the intimacy they'd both wanted for their actual vows.
"It's a good compromise," Chloe said, reviewing the final plan with Ethan late that evening. "Everyone gets something. Nobody gets everything they originally wanted, but everyone gets something real."
"That's probably the best any compromise can offer," Ethan said. "I'm glad we found this one, though. It feels considerably more sustainable than either of us simply capitulating entirely to the other's preferences."
"Or to Constance's," Chloe added, laughing.
"Especially Constance's," Ethan agreed, and pulled her close, the evening settling comfortably around them both, the wedding finally, genuinely taking shape into something that felt, at last, entirely their own.
Chloe's mother, when informed of the final venue decision, cried again, though this time from the particular joy of learning her own backyard would host the wedding she'd spent years quietly hoping to someday see her daughter have, exactly the kind of small, meaningful celebration that had nothing to do with orchids imported from anywhere at all, and everything to do with the people who actually mattered gathering together to witness something real.
It felt, Chloe thought, like exactly the right ending to a week that had begun with overwhelming production pressure and settled, gradually, into something considerably more true to who she and Ethan actually were.
Both of them, finally, entirely at peace with exactly where things stood.
You've reached the end of this chapter