The Lunaryth Sword was housed in a shrine that had clearly been designed to make visitors feel small.
This was not a criticism. It was an observation about architectural intent. The chamber was tall and narrow, which elongated the lines of sight toward the ceiling in a way that created an impression of height beyond the actual dimensions. The walls were carved with the same kind of purposeful, text-like symbols he'd seen throughout the building, but here they were more densely arranged, covering every surface from floor to near-ceiling in a pattern that was, he noted, actually quite beautiful when you stopped trying to read it. The light came from the same sourceless warmth as elsewhere, but concentrated here, focused somehow on the plinth at the center of the room and on the sword resting in it.
The sword was, objectively speaking, a remarkable object. The blade was something close to silver, or silver combined with something else, and it caught the light in a way that suggested it was doing something with the light rather than simply reflecting it. The hilt was wrapped in a material he could not identify from a distance. The plinth it rested in was carved from the same pale stone as the floor, with channels cut into the surface that ran to a central point beneath the blade.
He was escorted in by Lysera Vey and two members of the Oracle's staff. There were six other people already in the room, variously robed, two of whom were clearly high-ranking based on the deference offered to them by the others. They had come, he understood, to witness this viewing, which was a formal event of some kind.
Everyone stopped talking when he entered.
He looked at the sword.
He said: Does this have a certificate of provenance?
The silence that followed was, he reflected, probably the most complete silence he had generated in a professional context since the time he had asked a company's CFO whether the signature on a particularly important document was in fact the CFO's signature or whether perhaps it had been placed there by someone else with access to the CFO's stamp. The CFO had not answered that question either.
Lysera said, quietly, in the tone of someone intervening before something irretrievable happens: That is the Lunaryth Sword.
He said: I understand. Does it have documentation? A record of its origin, its chain of custody, its authentication?
It is a sacred artifact.
He looked at her. He said: I once audited a company that had categorized a photocopier as a strategic defense asset because one of their clients was a government contractor. The categorization affected the depreciation schedule, which affected the quarterly reports, which affected the stock valuation. The category doesn't determine what the thing is. What the thing is determines whether the category is accurate. The sword's categorization as sacred doesn't change what documentation it should have. If anything, the stakes of getting that categorization wrong seem higher here than in the photocopier situation.
She stared at him.
Then, against what appeared to be her better judgment, one corner of her mouth moved.
It was not a smile. It was the precursor to a smile, arrested very precisely before it became one, in the way that certain expressions are controlled by people who have trained themselves to control them. He noted it and did not comment on it.
He turned back to the sword.
I'd like to look at it more closely, he said. Is there a protocol for that?
There was a brief and clearly fraught exchange in Elyndor's language between Lysera and one of the high-ranking robed figures. Then Lysera said: You may approach. You may not touch the blade.
He approached.
He was aware that everyone in the room was holding their breath, in the specific way that rooms hold breath when someone is doing something that could go very wrong. He did not hurry. He walked to the plinth and looked at the sword with the same quality of attention he brought to documents: starting at the overall structure, then working inward toward specific elements.
The blade, up close, was definitely doing something with the light. Some kind of property in the material. He made a note of this without touching it.
The hilt was wrapped in something that was neither leather nor cloth, something with a faint texture that suggested it would interact differently with different hands. This was worth noting.
He looked at the plinth. The channels cut into it ran to a central depression beneath the blade. He looked at the depression. It was small, circular, precisely cut, the kind of precise cutting that suggested it was not decorative but functional. Its diameter was consistent with the diameter of a human fingertip.
He looked at the channels again. They ran outward from the central depression to the edges of the plinth. They were not drainage channels. They were too shallow and too precise for drainage. They were distribution channels, which implied that what was placed in the central depression was meant to flow outward in a specific pattern.
Blood, he thought. Or something blood-adjacent. Something that would flow, that would fill channels in a specific pattern, that would trigger something in the sword or the plinth when introduced through the central point.
He looked at Thalion Orr's hands the previous day. He had bandaging on the left hand, just below the thumb. He had not thought much about it at the time. Now he thought about it.
He stepped back from the plinth.
He said: Thank you. That was very informative.
One of the high-ranking figures said something in sharp, questioning tones. Lysera translated: He asks what you were looking for.
Renji thought about how to answer this accurately without producing an outcome that would be counterproductive. He said: I was verifying that the object matches its description in the historical record. Documentary due diligence. Entirely routine.
This appeared to satisfy no one, but it was not disputed.
He was escorted back out.
In the corridor, Lysera walked beside him. She did not say anything for a moment. Then she said, carefully, her eyes forward: You looked at the base of the plinth for a very long time.
He said: I was looking at the channels.
She said, still carefully: What did they tell you?
He considered for a moment. He said: That the mechanism requires a specific input. And that the input is determined by something other than what the ritual says determines it.
She stopped walking.
He stopped too and looked at her. She was looking at the middle distance, at something that was not in the corridor, and her expression had the quality he was coming to associate with her when something had confirmed rather than introduced a concern.
He said, because it seemed like the accurate thing to say: This isn't new information to you.
She said: The sword has been in the Archive's records for nine hundred years. I have catalogued every document related to it. I have read every analysis, every ceremonial account, every note.
He said: And?
She began walking again. He walked beside her.
She said: The earliest accounts describe the mechanism differently from the later ones. The later accounts emphasize divine selection. The earlier ones describe the mechanism in more specific terms. Terms that are consistent with what you have just described.
He said: When did the description change?
She said: Approximately three hundred years ago.
He wrote this in his mental notes, for transfer to paper later: 300 years. Same approximate period as the seal discrepancy he had already flagged. Same approximate period as the age of the copy in the corridor outside the High Oracle's chambers.
He said, not as an accusation but as a genuine question because he genuinely did not know: What happened in Elyndor three hundred years ago?
She said: It is a period of significant historical importance. There was conflict. There was significant loss.
He said: Between Elyndor and who?
She said: I will see you in the Archive tomorrow morning. Eight o'clock.
She walked away in the direction of a corridor he had not been taken down.
He stood in the corridor with his document bag and his pen and his increasingly long mental list of things that were three hundred years old and had not been compared with the things that came before them.
He wrote, that evening: the sword mechanism is consistent with biological identification, not divine selection. The description of this mechanism changed three hundred years ago, at approximately the same time as the seal discrepancy in the Prophecy copies. Lysera Vey knew this and did not tell me. She is telling me as much as she has decided to tell me, which is more than she has told anyone else, which means something.
He was reviewing the provenance records she had pulled for him the following day, the chain of custody documentation for the oldest copy of the Prophecy, when he found the gap.
Not a discrepancy in the document itself. A gap in the record of the document's handling: a period of eleven months, three hundred and four years ago, during which the oldest copy had no recorded location. It had been logged out of its storage location and had not been logged back in. The next entry in its record was from eleven months later, when it had been logged into its current location, with a note describing it as returned from restoration treatment.
He looked at the restoration records for that period.
There were no restoration records for that period. Or rather: there were restoration records, but they did not include any entry for this document.
He wrote: oldest copy of the Prophecy, missing from its documented location for eleven months, 304 years ago. Described as in restoration on return. No restoration record found. Cross-reference with the dates of the seal discrepancy: the seal is dated 308 years ago, which falls within the period before the eleven-month gap. The document was removed after the seal was applied and returned with the restoration note as cover.
He looked at this for a long time.
Then he wrote: this is not a rounding error. This is deliberate. Someone removed the oldest copy of the Prophecy, held it for eleven months, and returned it with a false conservation note. In my experience, the only reason to handle a document in this way is to alter it.
He went to find Lysera.
She was in the cataloguing room adjacent to the reading room, working with a set of documents that had the quality of something recent rather than ancient. She looked up when he came in.
He said: I need to show you something.
She came to look at the gap in the provenance records. She looked at it for a long time. Her expression did not change. But she sat down, which she had not done without being invited before.
She said: Eleven months.
He said: Yes.
She said: And the restoration records.
He said: Do not support the explanation given.
She sat with this for a moment. Then she said, quietly: My mother found something similar. Not the same thing. A different document with a gap in its handling record. She brought it to the Council. She was removed from the Archive within the month.
He said: I'm sorry.
She said: She was not wrong. She was just the wrong person to be right, at the wrong time, with the wrong audience.
He said: Tell me what she found.
And Lysera Vey told him, for the first time in sixty years, what her mother had actually found before the Archive had decided to expel her for finding it. She told him in the careful, precise way she told everything, with exact references and careful distinctions between what her mother had documented and what she had inferred. It took thirty minutes. He took notes throughout.
When she was done, he had a list that was longer than any list he had made so far, and every item on it was pointing in the same direction.
He said: Your mother was right.
She said: Yes.
He said: And you have known this for how long?
She said: Since I was old enough to understand what she had found. Since before I came to work in this Archive.
He said: You have been here for sixty years knowing that.
She said: Yes.
He said: Why stay?
She said: Because the alternative was to leave the documents in the hands of people who would not ask the questions my mother asked. And because I was waiting.
He said: For what?
She looked at him with the direct quality of her full attention, the quality she reserved for statements rather than observations.
She said: I don't know yet. But I think the waiting may be over.
They worked through the afternoon in the particular companionship that develops between people doing parallel work in the same room, a kind of shared quiet that was comfortable without requiring conversation. He read. She catalogued. Occasionally one of them would say something and the other would respond, and then the quiet would resume.
He noticed, somewhere in the fourth hour, that this was the first time he had been comfortable in a room with another person in a very long time. Not in an interesting way, not in a way he wanted to analyze. Just as a fact. The room was quiet and the work was there and she was at the other end of the table, and he was comfortable.
He wrote this in his notebook, in the personal column. Then he looked at it and thought about whether to cross it out.
He didn't cross it out.
At the end of the day she was leaving when she stopped in the doorway and said, without turning around, in the tone of someone saying something they have been carrying for a while: My mother's name was Aelindra Vey. She was an accurate person. Everything she found, she documented correctly. I want you to know that, before you proceed with this review, because her documentation is going to be relevant, and I want you to approach it knowing it is reliable.
He said: I understand.
She said: She was right, and it cost her everything, and she was still right. That matters.
He said: It does. He paused. I'll be careful with her work.
She nodded, the precise nod she used for conclusions, and left.
He sat for a moment after she was gone. Then he wrote: Aelindra Vey. She was right. Her daughter has spent sixty years in the archive where her mother was right and paid for it. That is the specific kind of patience that only comes from believing the truth is still there to be found.
The correspondence records contained, at the very back of the third cabinet he searched, a letter he had not expected.
It was old. Older than the modification period by at least a century. It was in a script he could not read without Lysera's help, and it was from a sender whose title he did not recognize, written to a recipient described only as the Keeper of the Green Binding.
Lysera, when he brought it to her, was quiet for a long moment before she translated.
The letter described a renewal ceremony performed at the end of a period of conflict. It described two parties to the renewal: the elves of Elyndor, and another party described as the people of the stone reaches. It described the ceremony as a reaffirmation of a covenant that predated the current kingdom by three generations. And it described the object in which the covenant was housed as a vessel of trust between two peoples, to be opened when trust was required.
He said: The vessel of trust.
She said: The same phrase as the one my mother found. The sword as a vessel of covenant.
He said: And the people of the stone reaches.
She said, very quietly: I know who that is.
He said: Tell me.
She looked at the letter for a long moment. Then she told him, and what she told him changed the shape of everything he had been building, made it larger and more complicated and more necessary.
The letter with the people of the stone reaches changed the topology of what he was investigating. It was no longer just about what the Prophecy said. It was about who the Prophecy had been changed to harm, and why, and whether the harm was still ongoing because the change was still in place.
This was not a rounding error. This was not a misclassified asset. This was three hundred years of documented injustice in the name of a document that had been deliberately falsified by the people who were supposed to be its guardians.
He had found things like this before. Not at this scale. Not with these stakes. But the same category. The same mechanism.
He knew what to do with it. He had always known. The only question, as always, was whether there was a channel that would respond.
He wrote, before he slept: Aelindra Vey was right. The covenant exists. It was never a prophecy. It was an agreement between two peoples, bent into a weapon by people who needed an enemy more than they needed the truth. I am going to find what it actually says. And when I find it, I will put it in a form that cannot be denied.
He thought: the covenant between two peoples, maintained in a vessel of trust, bent into a weapon. Three hundred years of a weapon made from an agreement. The people on the other end of the agreement had been living with the weapon pointed at them for three centuries. That was the part that landed heaviest, not the falsification of the document but the three hundred years of consequence that followed it for people who had done nothing but sign their name to something that was then used against them.
You've reached the end of this chapter
The Lunaryth Sword was housed in a shrine that had clearly been designed to make visitors feel small.
This was not a criticism. It was an observation about architectural intent. The chamber was tall and narrow, which elongated the lines of sight toward the ceiling in a way that created an impression of height beyond the actual dimensions. The walls were carved with the same kind of purposeful, text-like symbols he'd seen throughout the building, but here they were more densely arranged, covering every surface from floor to near-ceiling in a pattern that was, he noted, actually quite beautiful when you stopped trying to read it. The light came from the same sourceless warmth as elsewhere, but concentrated here, focused somehow on the plinth at the center of the room and on the sword resting in it.
The sword was, objectively speaking, a remarkable object. The blade was something close to silver, or silver combined with something else, and it caught the light in a way that suggested it was doing something with the light rather than simply reflecting it. The hilt was wrapped in a material he could not identify from a distance. The plinth it rested in was carved from the same pale stone as the floor, with channels cut into the surface that ran to a central point beneath the blade.
He was escorted in by Lysera Vey and two members of the Oracle's staff. There were six other people already in the room, variously robed, two of whom were clearly high-ranking based on the deference offered to them by the others. They had come, he understood, to witness this viewing, which was a formal event of some kind.
Everyone stopped talking when he entered.
He looked at the sword.
He said: Does this have a certificate of provenance?
The silence that followed was, he reflected, probably the most complete silence he had generated in a professional context since the time he had asked a company's CFO whether the signature on a particularly important document was in fact the CFO's signature or whether perhaps it had been placed there by someone else with access to the CFO's stamp. The CFO had not answered that question either.
Lysera said, quietly, in the tone of someone intervening before something irretrievable happens: That is the Lunaryth Sword.
He said: I understand. Does it have documentation? A record of its origin, its chain of custody, its authentication?
It is a sacred artifact.
He looked at her. He said: I once audited a company that had categorized a photocopier as a strategic defense asset because one of their clients was a government contractor. The categorization affected the depreciation schedule, which affected the quarterly reports, which affected the stock valuation. The category doesn't determine what the thing is. What the thing is determines whether the category is accurate. The sword's categorization as sacred doesn't change what documentation it should have. If anything, the stakes of getting that categorization wrong seem higher here than in the photocopier situation.
She stared at him.
Then, against what appeared to be her better judgment, one corner of her mouth moved.
It was not a smile. It was the precursor to a smile, arrested very precisely before it became one, in the way that certain expressions are controlled by people who have trained themselves to control them. He noted it and did not comment on it.
He turned back to the sword.
I'd like to look at it more closely, he said. Is there a protocol for that?
There was a brief and clearly fraught exchange in Elyndor's language between Lysera and one of the high-ranking robed figures. Then Lysera said: You may approach. You may not touch the blade.
He approached.
He was aware that everyone in the room was holding their breath, in the specific way that rooms hold breath when someone is doing something that could go very wrong. He did not hurry. He walked to the plinth and looked at the sword with the same quality of attention he brought to documents: starting at the overall structure, then working inward toward specific elements.
The blade, up close, was definitely doing something with the light. Some kind of property in the material. He made a note of this without touching it.
The hilt was wrapped in something that was neither leather nor cloth, something with a faint texture that suggested it would interact differently with different hands. This was worth noting.
He looked at the plinth. The channels cut into it ran to a central depression beneath the blade. He looked at the depression. It was small, circular, precisely cut, the kind of precise cutting that suggested it was not decorative but functional. Its diameter was consistent with the diameter of a human fingertip.
He looked at the channels again. They ran outward from the central depression to the edges of the plinth. They were not drainage channels. They were too shallow and too precise for drainage. They were distribution channels, which implied that what was placed in the central depression was meant to flow outward in a specific pattern.
Blood, he thought. Or something blood-adjacent. Something that would flow, that would fill channels in a specific pattern, that would trigger something in the sword or the plinth when introduced through the central point.
He looked at Thalion Orr's hands the previous day. He had bandaging on the left hand, just below the thumb. He had not thought much about it at the time. Now he thought about it.
He stepped back from the plinth.
He said: Thank you. That was very informative.
One of the high-ranking figures said something in sharp, questioning tones. Lysera translated: He asks what you were looking for.
Renji thought about how to answer this accurately without producing an outcome that would be counterproductive. He said: I was verifying that the object matches its description in the historical record. Documentary due diligence. Entirely routine.
This appeared to satisfy no one, but it was not disputed.
He was escorted back out.
In the corridor, Lysera walked beside him. She did not say anything for a moment. Then she said, carefully, her eyes forward: You looked at the base of the plinth for a very long time.
He said: I was looking at the channels.
She said, still carefully: What did they tell you?
He considered for a moment. He said: That the mechanism requires a specific input. And that the input is determined by something other than what the ritual says determines it.
She stopped walking.
He stopped too and looked at her. She was looking at the middle distance, at something that was not in the corridor, and her expression had the quality he was coming to associate with her when something had confirmed rather than introduced a concern.
He said, because it seemed like the accurate thing to say: This isn't new information to you.
She said: The sword has been in the Archive's records for nine hundred years. I have catalogued every document related to it. I have read every analysis, every ceremonial account, every note.
He said: And?
She began walking again. He walked beside her.
She said: The earliest accounts describe the mechanism differently from the later ones. The later accounts emphasize divine selection. The earlier ones describe the mechanism in more specific terms. Terms that are consistent with what you have just described.
He said: When did the description change?
She said: Approximately three hundred years ago.
He wrote this in his mental notes, for transfer to paper later: 300 years. Same approximate period as the seal discrepancy he had already flagged. Same approximate period as the age of the copy in the corridor outside the High Oracle's chambers.
He said, not as an accusation but as a genuine question because he genuinely did not know: What happened in Elyndor three hundred years ago?
She said: It is a period of significant historical importance. There was conflict. There was significant loss.
He said: Between Elyndor and who?
She said: I will see you in the Archive tomorrow morning. Eight o'clock.
She walked away in the direction of a corridor he had not been taken down.
He stood in the corridor with his document bag and his pen and his increasingly long mental list of things that were three hundred years old and had not been compared with the things that came before them.
He wrote, that evening: the sword mechanism is consistent with biological identification, not divine selection. The description of this mechanism changed three hundred years ago, at approximately the same time as the seal discrepancy in the Prophecy copies. Lysera Vey knew this and did not tell me. She is telling me as much as she has decided to tell me, which is more than she has told anyone else, which means something.
He was reviewing the provenance records she had pulled for him the following day, the chain of custody documentation for the oldest copy of the Prophecy, when he found the gap.
Not a discrepancy in the document itself. A gap in the record of the document's handling: a period of eleven months, three hundred and four years ago, during which the oldest copy had no recorded location. It had been logged out of its storage location and had not been logged back in. The next entry in its record was from eleven months later, when it had been logged into its current location, with a note describing it as returned from restoration treatment.
He looked at the restoration records for that period.
There were no restoration records for that period. Or rather: there were restoration records, but they did not include any entry for this document.
He wrote: oldest copy of the Prophecy, missing from its documented location for eleven months, 304 years ago. Described as in restoration on return. No restoration record found. Cross-reference with the dates of the seal discrepancy: the seal is dated 308 years ago, which falls within the period before the eleven-month gap. The document was removed after the seal was applied and returned with the restoration note as cover.
He looked at this for a long time.
Then he wrote: this is not a rounding error. This is deliberate. Someone removed the oldest copy of the Prophecy, held it for eleven months, and returned it with a false conservation note. In my experience, the only reason to handle a document in this way is to alter it.
He went to find Lysera.
She was in the cataloguing room adjacent to the reading room, working with a set of documents that had the quality of something recent rather than ancient. She looked up when he came in.
He said: I need to show you something.
She came to look at the gap in the provenance records. She looked at it for a long time. Her expression did not change. But she sat down, which she had not done without being invited before.
She said: Eleven months.
He said: Yes.
She said: And the restoration records.
He said: Do not support the explanation given.
She sat with this for a moment. Then she said, quietly: My mother found something similar. Not the same thing. A different document with a gap in its handling record. She brought it to the Council. She was removed from the Archive within the month.
He said: I'm sorry.
She said: She was not wrong. She was just the wrong person to be right, at the wrong time, with the wrong audience.
He said: Tell me what she found.
And Lysera Vey told him, for the first time in sixty years, what her mother had actually found before the Archive had decided to expel her for finding it. She told him in the careful, precise way she told everything, with exact references and careful distinctions between what her mother had documented and what she had inferred. It took thirty minutes. He took notes throughout.
When she was done, he had a list that was longer than any list he had made so far, and every item on it was pointing in the same direction.
He said: Your mother was right.
She said: Yes.
He said: And you have known this for how long?
She said: Since I was old enough to understand what she had found. Since before I came to work in this Archive.
He said: You have been here for sixty years knowing that.
She said: Yes.
He said: Why stay?
She said: Because the alternative was to leave the documents in the hands of people who would not ask the questions my mother asked. And because I was waiting.
He said: For what?
She looked at him with the direct quality of her full attention, the quality she reserved for statements rather than observations.
She said: I don't know yet. But I think the waiting may be over.
They worked through the afternoon in the particular companionship that develops between people doing parallel work in the same room, a kind of shared quiet that was comfortable without requiring conversation. He read. She catalogued. Occasionally one of them would say something and the other would respond, and then the quiet would resume.
He noticed, somewhere in the fourth hour, that this was the first time he had been comfortable in a room with another person in a very long time. Not in an interesting way, not in a way he wanted to analyze. Just as a fact. The room was quiet and the work was there and she was at the other end of the table, and he was comfortable.
He wrote this in his notebook, in the personal column. Then he looked at it and thought about whether to cross it out.
He didn't cross it out.
At the end of the day she was leaving when she stopped in the doorway and said, without turning around, in the tone of someone saying something they have been carrying for a while: My mother's name was Aelindra Vey. She was an accurate person. Everything she found, she documented correctly. I want you to know that, before you proceed with this review, because her documentation is going to be relevant, and I want you to approach it knowing it is reliable.
He said: I understand.
She said: She was right, and it cost her everything, and she was still right. That matters.
He said: It does. He paused. I'll be careful with her work.
She nodded, the precise nod she used for conclusions, and left.
He sat for a moment after she was gone. Then he wrote: Aelindra Vey. She was right. Her daughter has spent sixty years in the archive where her mother was right and paid for it. That is the specific kind of patience that only comes from believing the truth is still there to be found.
The correspondence records contained, at the very back of the third cabinet he searched, a letter he had not expected.
It was old. Older than the modification period by at least a century. It was in a script he could not read without Lysera's help, and it was from a sender whose title he did not recognize, written to a recipient described only as the Keeper of the Green Binding.
Lysera, when he brought it to her, was quiet for a long moment before she translated.
The letter described a renewal ceremony performed at the end of a period of conflict. It described two parties to the renewal: the elves of Elyndor, and another party described as the people of the stone reaches. It described the ceremony as a reaffirmation of a covenant that predated the current kingdom by three generations. And it described the object in which the covenant was housed as a vessel of trust between two peoples, to be opened when trust was required.
He said: The vessel of trust.
She said: The same phrase as the one my mother found. The sword as a vessel of covenant.
He said: And the people of the stone reaches.
She said, very quietly: I know who that is.
He said: Tell me.
She looked at the letter for a long moment. Then she told him, and what she told him changed the shape of everything he had been building, made it larger and more complicated and more necessary.
The letter with the people of the stone reaches changed the topology of what he was investigating. It was no longer just about what the Prophecy said. It was about who the Prophecy had been changed to harm, and why, and whether the harm was still ongoing because the change was still in place.
This was not a rounding error. This was not a misclassified asset. This was three hundred years of documented injustice in the name of a document that had been deliberately falsified by the people who were supposed to be its guardians.
He had found things like this before. Not at this scale. Not with these stakes. But the same category. The same mechanism.
He knew what to do with it. He had always known. The only question, as always, was whether there was a channel that would respond.
He wrote, before he slept: Aelindra Vey was right. The covenant exists. It was never a prophecy. It was an agreement between two peoples, bent into a weapon by people who needed an enemy more than they needed the truth. I am going to find what it actually says. And when I find it, I will put it in a form that cannot be denied.
He thought: the covenant between two peoples, maintained in a vessel of trust, bent into a weapon. Three hundred years of a weapon made from an agreement. The people on the other end of the agreement had been living with the weapon pointed at them for three centuries. That was the part that landed heaviest, not the falsification of the document but the three hundred years of consequence that followed it for people who had done nothing but sign their name to something that was then used against them.
You've reached the end of this chapter