Chapter 6: The Question Marcus Already Knew the Answer To
Marcus's invitation arrived by text message rather than through any of the formal channels the Vance family typically used, which Chloe noted, filed away, and didn't mention to Ethan until they were already in the car.
*Lunch Thursday? Small place near the office, nothing formal. Would love to get to know Chloe better before we're all family officially. — M*
"He texted you directly," Ethan said, reading over her shoulder at a red light, something tightening in his jaw.
"Is that unusual?"
"He doesn't have your number. Which means he got it from someone." Ethan's fingers drummed once against the steering wheel. "I'd like to know who."
"Should I say no?"
"No," Ethan said, after a moment's consideration. "Saying no gives him something to wonder about. Better to go, be pleasant, give him nothing interesting to work with." He glanced at her. "But tell me everything he asks. Word for word, if you can manage it."
"You make him sound like an interrogation, not a cousin."
"He's very good at making interrogations feel like lunch," Ethan said, and didn't elaborate further, and Chloe found herself, not for the first time, wishing he'd trust her with more of whatever history sat behind that particular caution. "He's my father's brother's son," Ethan added, after a pause, as if that explained something significant. "We were close, as children. Before the succession fight, before any of us understood what the family actually was. I used to think of him as the brother I didn't have." His jaw tightened. "I still don't entirely know how to reconcile that memory with who he's become. Or whether he's actually become anything different at all, and I simply didn't see it clearly enough as a child to notice."
"That sounds lonely," Chloe said, echoing, without quite meaning to, the same words she'd used about his family days earlier.
"It's familiar," he said again, and this time the repetition landed heavier between them, like an admission neither of them had quite intended to make twice.
---
The restaurant Marcus chose was, true to his word, small and unpretentious — a narrow Italian place two blocks from Apex Media that Chloe suspected he'd selected specifically because it photographed as humble rather than because he actually preferred the food. He was already seated when they arrived, standing to greet them both with a warmth that would have read as entirely genuine to anyone who hadn't already been warned.
"Chloe. So glad you could make it." He kissed her cheek, European-formal, and held the chair for her himself before the server could reach it. "Ethan tells me almost nothing about you, which I've decided to take as evidence you're worth protecting rather than evidence he's hiding something."
"Or evidence I'm simply not that interesting," Chloe said, settling into her seat. "He didn't ask me anything about you, specifically," Chloe added, once they were seated at the restaurant table, the wine poured and the bread untouched between them. "Not directly. Everything was framed as being about me. But it felt, the whole time, like he was actually trying to learn something about the two of us together — how solid this is, maybe, or how quickly it might come apart under pressure."
"That sounds like Marcus," Ethan said grimly. "He rarely asks the question he actually wants answered. He asks three adjacent ones and assembles the answer himself afterward."
"That's exhausting to be around."
"You have no idea," Ethan said, with the particular weariness of someone who'd spent a lifetime being exhausted by the same person and had simply learned to carry it quietly.
"I doubt that very much." Marcus smiled, and it was, objectively, a good smile — warm, symmetrical, the kind that had probably worked on dozens of people before her. "Tell me, where were you working before Apex? I like to know people's whole story, not just the chapter where they meet my favorite cousin."
"Crisis communications, mostly. Smaller agency before this, nothing you'd have heard of."
"Try me. I know more about the industry than people expect."
Chloe named the agency, watched something flicker briefly behind Marcus's eyes — recognition, or the performance of it, she genuinely couldn't tell which — before he nodded and let the subject go with a smoothness that felt, in retrospect, entirely too practiced. The server brought bread and a bottle of wine Marcus hadn't asked either of them to approve, pouring generously, and for a few minutes the conversation drifted somewhere safer — Marcus recounting a story about a sailing trip gone wrong off Nantucket, Ethan contributing exactly enough to seem engaged without volunteering anything of substance, Chloe watching the two of them navigate a familiarity that felt, beneath its warmth, oddly adversarial, like two chess players discussing the weather between moves.
"You two make a good match, you know," Marcus said, apropos of nothing, topping off Chloe's glass without asking. "I confess I was surprised when I heard. Ethan's never been one for spontaneity."
"People change," Chloe said, the same line she'd used at the family dinner, wondering distantly how many more times she'd need to deploy it before someone finally called her on the repetition.
"Do they?" Marcus's eyes, for just a moment, held something sharper than the polite curiosity of the rest of the conversation. "I've always found people change considerably less than they'd like to believe. Circumstances change. People mostly just adapt to fit them."
"That's a bit cynical for lunch conversation," Ethan said, his tone light but his eyes not matching it.
"I'm an incurable cynic. Ask anyone in the family." Marcus smiled, and the moment passed, but Chloe found she couldn't quite shake the sense that the comment had been aimed somewhere specific, and that she'd been standing exactly where it landed.
"And before that? You strike me as someone with an interesting past. Ethan collects interesting people, even when he pretends otherwise."
"Local news internship, then a truly humiliating stint writing copy for artisanal candles," Chloe said, deploying the joke she'd used successfully once before, watching it land considerably less well this time — Marcus's laugh a half-second too calculated, his eyes moving, briefly, toward Ethan in a way that felt like he was checking something rather than simply enjoying the story.
"Fascinating," Marcus said. "And no connections to any of Apex's competitors? I only ask because the industry's small, and I'd hate for old professional relationships to complicate things down the line."
Something in Chloe went very still. It was, on its surface, an innocuous question — the kind any curious relative might ask. But there was a precision to it, a specificity that suggested Marcus already knew the answer and was testing whether she'd volunteer it truthfully.
"None that I can think of," she said, keeping her voice light, professional. "It's a competitive field. People move around."
"Of course," Marcus said, smiling again, and moved the conversation smoothly toward something else entirely, and Chloe spent the rest of the lunch with the distinct, uncomfortable sensation of having passed a test she hadn't known she was taking.
---
She thought, replaying the lunch afterward, of the specific way Marcus's eyes had moved to Ethan whenever she mentioned her professional past — checking, always checking, as though her answers were only half the data he was collecting and Ethan's reactions to them were the other half. It left her with the unsettling sense that whatever game Marcus was playing, she and Ethan weren't just targets. They were, perhaps, being observed as a single unit, tested for weak points where the seam between real and performed might eventually show.
"He asked about competitors," Chloe said, once they were back in the car, the words coming out faster than she'd intended. "Specifically. Not casually — like he already had an answer he was checking against mine."
Ethan's expression sharpened, the easy caution from the drive over hardening into something more focused. "What did you tell him?"
"The truth. That I don't have any current connections to competitors." She hesitated. "Ethan, why would he care about that?"
"I don't know yet." He said it plainly, without the reflexive reassurance she half-expected. "But I intend to find out." "Do you think he knows something," Chloe asked, "or is he just fishing?"
"With Marcus, it's rarely one or the other cleanly." Ethan's hands tightened briefly on the wheel. "He collects small pieces of information the way other people collect stamps — not always because they're useful immediately, but because eventually, if you have enough of them, you can assemble something dangerous."
"That's a very specific way to describe a cousin."
"He's a very specific kind of cousin." Ethan exhaled, some of the tension leaving his shoulders as they turned onto their street. "I'd rather not speculate further until I actually know something concrete. Speculation with Marcus tends to become self-fulfilling if you're not careful."
They drove in silence for several blocks before he spoke again, his voice careful, deliberately casual in a way that told her the question underneath it wasn't casual at all. "Your last company — the one before the agency. What happened there? You've mentioned it twice now without ever finishing the story."
Chloe felt something in her chest constrict. She hadn't realized she'd mentioned it twice; she'd thought she was better at not letting it show.
"There was a boss," she said finally, watching the city slide by rather than looking at him. "Adrian. Everyone thought he was strict but fair, the way everyone thinks that about men like that until they're not anymore. I was honest with him — too honest, apparently — in emails I thought were private, about decisions I disagreed with. He used them. Built a story out of my own words that made me look insubordinate, difficult, not a team player. I lost the job. Took me eight months to find another one, because by then there were whispers."
"That's why you diffuse everything with jokes," Ethan said quietly. It wasn't a question.
"That's why I learned to perform whatever version of myself a room needed," Chloe said. "The honest version doesn't get promoted. She gets fired and blacklisted for having opinions in writing." She hadn't meant to tell him the whole story, not really — she'd meant to give him the shorthand version, the sanitized summary she'd used with the few friends who knew any of it at all. But something about the quiet of the car, the absence of any audience to perform for, had loosened something she usually kept carefully sealed.
"I still have the emails saved," she admitted, surprising herself. "Not because I ever plan to use them. I think I just needed proof, somewhere, that what happened actually happened the way I remembered it. That I wasn't the one who'd been unreasonable."
"You weren't," Ethan said, with a certainty that startled her. "I've read a hundred versions of that story, in a hundred different forms, sitting on our own board. It's never the honest person who was unreasonable. It's always just easier to say it was."
Ethan didn't respond immediately, and when she finally looked at him, she found him watching the road with an expression she hadn't seen on him before — not pity, which she would have hated, but something closer to genuine anger on her behalf, controlled and quiet.
"He shouldn't have been able to do that to you," he said finally.
"People like that usually can. That's the whole problem."
"Not always," Ethan said, something in his voice that sounded, for the first time since she'd known him, less like a CEO reciting a principle and more like a promise he intended to actually keep. "Not around me, if I can help it."
---
They didn't speak again until they were back at the penthouse, and even then it was quiet — not uncomfortable, but the particular quiet of two people who'd just exchanged something neither of them had planned to give away. Chloe made tea she didn't especially want, mostly for something to do with her hands, and found Ethan already seated at the kitchen island when she turned around, two mugs set out instead of one, as though he'd anticipated she'd need the company.
"Thank you," she said, "for not making that into something bigger than it was."
"I don't know how to respond to something like that without making it bigger than it is," Ethan admitted. "So I'm choosing to just sit here instead, if that's all right."
"That's more than all right." She sat across from him, mug warm between her hands, feeling something loosen in her chest that had been tight for longer than she cared to examine. "Most people either pity you or try to fix it. You're doing neither."
"I don't know how to fix something like that. I only know how to make sure it doesn't happen again on my watch." He said it simply, without performance, and Chloe found herself believing him completely — a dangerous thing to believe, given everything else she wasn't yet telling him.
"For what it's worth," she said, "I don't think you're anything like Adrian."
Something crossed his face — relief, maybe, or something adjacent to it — and he didn't say anything, just nodded once, and the silence that followed was, for the first time since she'd moved into this apartment, entirely comfortable. They sat with that for a while, the tea long gone cold in front of them, neither of them in any particular hurry to break the quiet. Chloe found herself studying him in the low kitchen light — the careful stillness he carried even now, the way his hands, usually so precise, had gone loose and unguarded around his mug — and thought that this, whatever this was, felt considerably more dangerous to her than the six-month contract had ever accounted for. Contracts didn't have clauses for this. There was no rule, out of the hundred she'd written, that covered what to do when the fake fiancee started feeling less and less like a role and more like the truest version of a friendship she'd had in years.
"Can I ask you something," she said, before she'd fully decided to, "and you don't have to answer if it's too much?"
"Go ahead."
"Was there really no one, before this? Someone worth mentioning, I mean. Not just the person from London you mentioned once and then closed the door on."
Something shifted behind his eyes — not quite pain, but its close relative, the kind of expression that suggested a wound handled carefully rather than one that had fully healed. "There was someone," he said finally. "It ended badly enough that I've spent most of the time since deciding not to repeat the experience. That's the most I'm able to give you tonight."
"That's fair," Chloe said, and meant it, filing the answer away next to everything else about him she was slowly, carefully collecting, piece by piece, the way he seemed to be collecting pieces of her in return. He thought, not for the first time, about how easily she'd disarmed a table full of strangers who'd known him his whole life, and how much harder it had apparently been for her to trust a single person with the truth about her own past. It struck him as a strange kind of asymmetry — that the person so skilled at managing everyone else's crises had spent years managing her own alone, with no one assigned to help contain the damage.
He didn't say any of that aloud. He suspected she'd find it too close to pity, however carefully he meant it, and pity was clearly the last thing she wanted from anyone tonight. Instead he simply refilled her tea, unprompted, and let the quiet stretch on exactly as long as she needed it to.
---
Later that night, once Chloe had retreated to her own wing, Ethan sat alone in his study with his laptop open to a search bar he'd been staring at for several minutes without typing anything into it.
Marcus's question replayed in his head, over and over, alongside the memory of the email fragment he'd glimpsed days earlier — *Silverline Pictures*, *your novel*, *anonymous authors* — two separate pieces of incomplete information that some instinct told him, without any evidence yet to support it, were connected in a way he didn't fully understand.
He typed Marcus's name into the search bar, then his cousin's known business associates, scrolling through results that told him nothing he didn't already know. Whatever Marcus was doing, he was doing it carefully enough to leave no obvious trail.
He closed the laptop eventually, unsatisfied, and told himself he'd raise it properly with his head of corporate security in the morning — a quiet inquiry, nothing alarming, just due diligence on a cousin who'd never quite let go of a grudge fifteen years old. He thought about calling his head of security that night rather than waiting for morning, then reconsidered — a call placed at midnight would draw exactly the kind of attention he was trying to avoid, the kind of internal chatter that could reach Marcus faster than any answers could reach him. Patience, he reminded himself, was usually the more effective weapon, however unsatisfying it felt in the moment.
What he didn't do, though he considered it for a long moment, was mention any of it to Chloe. Not because he didn't trust her. Because some part of him, still cautious after tonight's unexpected honesty, wanted to protect whatever fragile thing had just started growing between them a little longer before he introduced anything as complicated as Marcus into it. "For what it's worth," Ethan said quietly, before they got out of the car, "whatever he's building toward, I'd rather face it with someone I trust standing next to me than alone, the way I've handled everything else in this family my whole life. I don't say that lightly."
"I'll take that as a compliment," Chloe said, "even though it sounds suspiciously like you're recruiting me for a war I didn't sign up to fight."
"You signed a contract," Ethan said, and there was the faintest trace of a smile in it. "I'm fairly certain a war against my own cousin falls under 'unforeseen circumstances,' section eleven."
"There is no section eleven about wars."
"There is now," he said. "I added it while you weren't looking."
She laughed, surprised into it, and the sound of it followed them both up to the apartment, lighter than either of them had expected the evening to end.
You've reached the end of this chapter